Grand Hyatt Baha Mar edges ahead if you want the full resort experience without breaking the bank, while Rosewood is the move for families comfortable spending more for spa-quality finesse and villa space. Both tap into the massive Baha Mar complex, so you're not choosing between limited options. If you're watching the budget, Comfort Suites gets you Atlantis Aquaventure access at half the Atlantis room rate—a genuine structural win. The Atlantis properties themselves deliver more spectacle and marine draw, but they cost more to stay and eat; factor that in upfront.