For 14- and 16-year-olds, you're past the "endless kids club" phase, so these picks lean on two angles: Grand Hyatt Baha Mar brings that polished, multi-generational appeal with real resort infrastructure (pools, program options if they want them, actual dining beyond chicken fingers). Rosewood Baha Mar goes premium-quiet if your crew prefers less hustle. Both sit in the same sprawling complex, so boredom isn't a concern. Comfort Suites and Atlantis are the value plays if waterpark access is your main draw; just know you're trading refinement for dollar savings and slides.