At 14 and 16, your kids are past the elementary-focused resort circuit but not quite ready to be parked in a regular adult hotel. The Bahamas resorts that work best here split into two lanes: Grand Hyatt Baha Mar delivers the most balanced experience—enough structure (Camp Hyatt) to keep teens occupied without feeling babyish, plus casino access for adults and serious pools—at a more defensible price than the ultra-premium tier. If budget allows, Rosewood Baha Mar offers the same Baha Mar amenities but with quieter, more grown-up vibes and shared access to everything. The waterpark plays (Atlantis, Comfort Suites) skew younger; Margaritaville's charm fades fast for this age group. Resorts here aren't all-inclusive, so budget dining separately.